Panasonic admits to using stock photos on its mirrorless camera 'LUMIX S9' product website and apologizes
Panasonic's full-frame mirrorless camera 'LUMIX S9' product website has been criticized for using stock photos in its feature explanations. In response to the uproar, Panasonic has issued an apology.
Regarding images on the LUMIX S9 product website
(PDF file)https://panasonic.jp/content/dam/panasonic/jp/ja/dc/pdf/about_S9_site.pdf
After the product page for the LUMIX S9 was released, it was pointed out that the photos used to explain the camera's performance were stock photos.
I said that the marketing was a failure, but that I appreciated the challenge, but I'm sorry, I'm not just taking back what I said. It was the exact opposite.
— HertZ (@zaq_de_la_rocha) May 27, 2024
Not only are they not Flickr photos, but the S9 product page is full of copyright-free photos, almost all of which are stock photos. Even the photo of the camera screen is inlaid in some places.
Continued #lumix https://t.co/WVCkOzQwNr
In fact, if you search for the dog photo on the product page, the same photo comes up, which shows that it is a stock photo. This photo of the dog was used to explain the autofocus (AF) function of the LUMIX S9, but if you don't know anything about it, you might mistake it for an example of a photo taken with the LUMIX S9.
Image explaining this AF.
— HertZ (@zaq_de_la_rocha) May 27, 2024
The blurred part in the background had a lot of tone jumps, and I wondered what kind of lens was used to make it look like this. Then it turned out like this... I had the biggest double take of the Reiwa era. #lumix pic.twitter.com/r1rTIedQCV
In addition, a page explaining color grading for video was found to use stock photos. The page explains how to change the color and contrast of a video by applying a lookup table (LUT), but the explanation uses stock photos instead of actual video captures.
The product introduction site for the Lumix S9 has been getting a lot of attention. I took a look and was surprised to see that the images used were the same as photos of a dog run I know, and even the images showcasing the main features were free materials.
— sonapapa (@sonapapa57577) May 27, 2024
There are some photos that seem to require credit, but I wonder if they're okay... #S9 #Panasonic pic.twitter.com/00EToc2uiG
Additionally, the lava photo used on the explanatory page for the 4K footage was also a stock photo.
The Lumix example is a photo stock. It's amazing how you can come across stock photos just by searching for random images () pic.twitter.com/FMeFq56pyc
— Lee Kemen (@i_kemen) May 27, 2024
In addition, it was discovered that stock photos were used not only on the product page for the LUMIX S9, but also on the product page for the full-frame single-lens camera DC-S1R.
On the DC-S1R page, there was a stock photo showing the image quality, but I wonder if the photographer who took this photo took it with the DC-S1R and then added it to the stock photo list? pic.twitter.com/6WLwv8Ilzi
— Lee Kemen (@i_kemen) May 27, 2024
It has also been pointed out that many stock photos are used on the lens introduction pages.
The LUMIX website has been in the spotlight since yesterday, with stock photos appearing one after another on the pages introducing each lens. This is just too dishonest. https://t.co/2MhxD54sor https://t.co/5qv3Mhzl5Q https://t.co/4v1GGnEWSR https://t.co/TtWQGErGt3 pic.twitter.com/nIuwFMe94T
— HIROPON (@hiropon_hp2) May 28, 2024
Although each page does state that 'the images and illustrations are for illustrative purposes only,' this is written in very small letters and in an inconspicuous place, so it is inevitable that people who see the pages will mistake the stock photos for actual examples.
At the time of writing, the series of images had been removed from the product website, and the photographs were labeled 'for illustrative purposes only' or the model name. Panasonic also issued a statement of apology in response to the series of criticisms.
To all LUMIX and camera fans
— LUMIX JAPAN (@LUMIX_Japan) May 28, 2024
We have received many inquiries regarding the LUMIX S9 product website.
Our announcement has been posted on the product website. Please take a look. https://t.co/DUGYruJk5B
The contents are as follows.
We have received many inquiries regarding the images on the product website for the new LUMIX S9 full-frame mirrorless interchangeable-lens camera.
Some of the images used on the product website to introduce functions and scenes were licensed from a stock photo service.
In addition to there having been insufficient consideration given to whether the photo was appropriate for a product page of a camera that generates creative content, the note explaining that the photo was not taken with a new product was written in a way and in a place that was difficult for customers to understand.
We are taking your comments seriously, reassessing our understanding, making the content easier to understand, and striving to communicate with our users in a way that is considerate of our users. We will continue to discuss reviewing the content of the LUMIX website so that we can meet your expectations as a camera manufacturer.
We would like to sincerely apologize to all of you who regularly use our products, as well as to all of you LUMIX and camera fans, for the concern and anxiety that this situation has caused.
All of us involved promise to engage with you more sincerely and bring about change, and we are reaffirming our resolve.
However, Panasonic has not explained how it began using stock photos, or why stock photos are being used on product sites other than the LUMIX S9.
Related Posts: